Skip to main content

Winning the academic game: How studying in Higher Education is just another game

While undergoing one of my annual clear-outs of unused files, I discovered this rather good wee article I wrote with the help of two esteemed colleagues, David Arnaud and Alan Grundy - Lor' bless 'em both...



The easiest way to understand anything new is to see it in terms of something we already know. Imagine, for example, seeing a zebra for the first time. Perhaps the first thing that would occur to you is that you had just encountered a very strange looking horse! In the same way, someone coming new to the academic world of Higher Education can find it is useful to have something to compare it with – something we are already familiar with. Since everyone knows what is involved in playing a game, this seems to be a useful place to start.



Start with what you know


Using analogies in this way is something we can often do, in all kinds of new situations, in order that we might have a more familiar and reassuring reference point. For example, I remember when I started in Higher Education myself. I used my experience of starting secondary school as a model – initially I felt a little threatened by the unknown quality of a new place and new people and it took me a little time to find my feet. Finding the same unknown, threatening quality at college I used my previous experience at school as reassurance. ‘I have been here before’ I told myself, ‘and it’s nothing to worry about’.

The first idea then, refers to the general process whereby we constantly use analogies to make sense of novel situations – starting Higher Education can be like starting school or taking up a new job. It can be like driving to a place you have never been or putting on a snorkel to and peering into the strange world of the sea.


For this article, we have used the analogy of playing a game. Why?  Because the analogy with games is the very best way of understanding what Higher Education is all about.

Interesting. But how exactly is academic study like a game?

Like all figurative exercises, there are countless possibilities, but here are a few ideas of mine for starters:


Almost any activity can be made into a game. Kicking a ball around is one thing. Add some rules specifying what players can and cannot do, and now you have football. Change the rules slightly and the activity becomes American Football, or Australian Rules football, or even rugby. Knowing what the rules are makes it possible to play the game and become good at it.

In the same way there are rules about how academic work is undertaken and presented. Some of these are rather tricky. Commit a foul in football and you will get a yellow card. Do it again and you get sent off. If you copy another person’s work and present it as you own this is called plagiary or plagiarism and you will get a warning (a yellow card, if you like). Do it again and you will get sent off!

And yet, another rule of academic work is that we have to undertake a great deal of research and include this in our essays.  So how can we do this and at the same time avoid a yellow card for plagiary?

Tricky! Tricky for us as well as for you. We need to make clear the rules we use when marking your work, just as a referee needs to make sure footballers know his decisions are made according to the rules, and that he is not simply making them up.

Knowing the rules of how academic work is put together and then how it is marked will help you become good at it.


‘Practice makes perfect’. This is fairly obvious, but being obvious does not make it any less true. On the one hand there is some truth that some individuals have ‘naturally’ good hand/eye co-ordination which makes them good at certain sports. For most sportsmen and women though, it’s a matter of practising and perfecting basic skills. Again, the same is true with academic study. More than this though, however it may be that we associate academic with intellectual activity and capacity, reading and writing (those key skills through which that activity find expression) are also practical activities which improve with constant practice.


PLAY

I suppose it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that studying for a degree is a serious business, involving a great deal of time, effort and money. All this is true but, again, its useful to see the parallels with games.


‘I like playing cricket‘ conveys (in a way that ‘I am doing cricket’ does not) the idea that we derive intrinsic pleasure from certain activities which appear to have no obvious or rational purpose. The Dutch historian Johan Huizinga called this the Ludic Principle and suggested that it was a central feature of human life. Playing the academic game is a challenge because it is a difficult game to master, but it also provides its own intrinsic rewards in addition to any formal prizes (good results, better career prospects, etc.) it may deliver along the way.


So – the academic game is a challenge. For many it will be completely new, so everyone needs to find out exactly what the rules are. When we know the rules, then we practice. The more we practice, the better we get and the more enjoyable it becomes.

Well – that’s the idea…!

Popular posts from this blog

2) Introduction to morphemes

So does language begin with words?

No. Language begins with sounds. It is important to understand this first and foremost. We have already raised this point, but it is worth raising again – language begins with sounds!

If I appear to be emphasizing this with a rather bizarre desperation, it is because it would be easy to think that since we are beginning our exploration of language and linguistics with words that this is where language begins. When you think about it logically though, all words are composed of various sounds grouped together. The word ‘cat’ is composed of three distinct sounds - /c/, /a/ and /t/.

So why aren’t we starting with looking at how sounds create language?

Well, in the not-too-distant past, when European football used to be free on the telly, Manchester United or Arsenal would jet off to Spain for a titanic contest with Barcelona. When the commentators referred to Barcelona, they would pronounce it ‘Bar-se-low-nah’ (bɑ:sɜ:ləʊnæ). After a few years th…

A fond farewell

Every time a new term starts, I find myself wondering what the hell happened to the supposed weeks inbetween?  We leap from teaching, to marking, to assessment boards to enrolments - and after all that, BANG!  Back in the classroom!  At which point we often start wishing there had been at least some time to prepare our classes...

But things have been rather different this time.  About a three months ago I was (admittedly to my own surprise) considered worthy enough to be offered an incredibly exciting job with the Centre for Excellence in Learning and Teaching (CELT) and the University of East London.  The regular whirlwind of activity over the Summer then, is having something of a more terminal period: Teaching, marking, assessment boards, enrolments and BANG! I'm walking out of Newham College for the last time!

It is now almost exactly 10 years since I joined Newham College.  The plan then was, at heart, very simple: The residents of Newham Borough represented a vast population …

Moodle looks rubbish: The myth that may be costing HE institutions

It was interesting, but not entirely surprising to read Phil Hill's blog on e-Literate suggesting a dramatic slow-down in the take-up of Moodle in HE Institutions.  Not surprising because there seems to be a myth about Moodle that has always flickered in dark corners and is fanned into flame by for-profit LMS providers at the nearest opportunity.

This myth is that Moodle looks rubbish.

Other LMS providers set up a course content page filled with as many html5 gadgets as they can imagine, and compare it to the most basic topic-format Moodle page.  "There we are!" they declare, "Look how rubbish Moodle looks compared to our system!  And in the modern world where students are using tablets and mobile phones more and more, isn't it important that your University LMS looks smart and contemporary?"

And so Universities look at these other LMS systems and think: 'Ooo, it has this, or it has that!  Our Moodle doesn't have them!'  Which in turn prompts a…